A Vulture Must-Read Book of October 2025
A Literary Hub Most Anticipated Book of 2025
“Instead of falling into clichés or sentimentality about mental health, deBoer presents Alice’s struggles with bleak humor and emotional clarity. His compelling novel . . . [grapples] unflinchingly with [mental illness] and modern alienation in a way that will captivate readers.”
—Booklist, starred review
“The core of this compact novel is so tough and powerful. It has the verisimilitude of a case study and the dread of an existential drama.”
—Sam Sacks, The Wall Street Journal
“[The Mind Reels’s] power lies in its relentless banality—the mind churning while life’s machinery grinds on.”
—The New Yorker
“Slim but powerful, gripping without making any effort to manipulate the reader through a redemptive plot arc or even milking sympathy.”
—John Warner, The Chicago Tribune
“We don’t have a solution for the Alices of the world. . . . But after reading this novel, perhaps some people might have a smidgen more of sympathy for Alice, for Jordan Neely—even for themselves.”
—Valerie Pavilonis, The Dispatch
“Our current mental health discourse . . . treats psychological illness as a charming personality quirk. . . . The Mind Reels is a corrective to such assumptions. Alice’s decline is not sexy or romantic—it’s like watching a car crash unfold in slow motion.”
—Will Collins, The Washington Examiner
“A searing portrait of a woman on the brink.”
—Publishers Weekly
"The Mind Reels names the horrible, terrifying slog of mental illness. The episodic mania and sexuality that other books quietly glorify aren't titillating in the slightest. They're merely reported for what they are; harrowing experiences of human illness. DeBoer doesn't present them clinically or indulgently. He presents them honestly."
—Neal Brennan
“One of the most precise and harrowing depictions of mental illness I’ve ever read. This is a relentless, compassionate, and beautiful debut novel. I couldn’t look away.”
—Andrew Martin, author of Cool for America
“The Mind Reels is that rarest of things: a novel that is genuinely important. DeBoer delivers truths about mental illness that many of us may find both surprising and haunting. That he does this in the context of a novel that is beautifully written, character-driven and pulsing with forward momentum makes it a real artistic achievement as well as an intellectual one.”
—Adelle Waldman, author of Help Wanted